Youngstown Prosecutor Says Investigation To Proceed In Priest Abuse Case

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 6/11/2009 7:49 pm

When we first heard from Bishop George Murry earlier this week about this alleged sexual misconduct, the Bishop said the victim told him he understood the statute of limitations for any criminal charges would have passed long ago.

But after some extensive research, the local prosecutor tells me today that may not necessarily be accurate.  Atty. Jay Macejko says, "it appears that there is an argument to make that this is a viable case." The prosecutor says there are at least three other sexual abuse cases on the books suggesting an investigation of Father Thomas Crum can be pursued.

Crum was placed on administrative leave by Youngstown Bishop George Murry last week after it was learned Crum engaged in sexual misconduct with a minor back in the mid-70's.  At the time Crum was on the faculty at Cardinal Mooney High School and the alleged victim was a student there.  On Tuesday, the Bishop told reporters the victim was now requesting anonymity, saying that day, "I will honor the request of the victim."

A spokesperson for the Diocese is now saying that covers a letter reportedly sent from the alleged victim to the Bishop last month detailing the accusations -- which led to a police report being filed.  The spokesperson says the Bishop does not want that letter turned over to authorities.  Macejko tells us he'll go to court if he has to to uncover the information he needs to decide if the case can be prosecuted or not, saying, I think that I would not be serving my duties if I tried to make a determination," before seeing the evidence.

Now to be sure -- the prosecutor admits at this point he has no way of knowing if there really is anything he can do with this case -- saying he first needs to see any and all potential evidence.

He says he fully anticipates there will be some resistance from the Diocese -- but is hoping both sides can work -- in his words -- as partners -- to see this through to its conclusion.

Share
4 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

CarolZ - 6/12/2009 12:50 PM
This case shows how important it is for victims of sexual abuse by clergy to report the crime to the Police and make a full police report. One victim alone is sometimes not enough for a satisfyingly full police investigation or prosecution to result. Together, the reports of multiple victims can begin to show a pattern of abuse by specific clergy member, be they Priests, Rabbi's, Imams, Protestant Clergy members or any other religious leader. If you have been abused by a religious leader or clergy member, you might have a stronger case than you think if others have reported crimes committed by the same person. You might feel there is little to be done based on your own police report. Report it anyway. You might be surprised to find your claim supported by the police reports of other victims of the same person who abused you. You are important - take yourself seriously and make a report. There may be more victims out there who can benefit from your speaking out and who will stand in solidarity with you. Carol Z, Columbus, OH SNAP Leader

CarolZ - 6/12/2009 12:42 PM
This case shows how important it is for victims of abuse by Clergy (of any denomination or faith) to report their abuse to the police and file a formal police report. It is always possible that other victims have reported their abuse. Any one of their claims may separately hold little legal weight but together their experiences begin to form a case against the abusive clergy member. Carol Z, Columbus SNAP Leader

JudyJones - 6/11/2009 9:31 PM
continued “No one should ever assume it’s ‘too late’ to call law enforcement,” said Jones. “Police and prosecutors are getting increasingly savvy and determined to pursue even older sex crimes, and laws are changing to make that more possible.” Civil lawsuits are sometimes possible even decades after the crimes happened. “Anyone who was hurt by Crum owes it to themselves and their families to explore all their legal options,” Jones said. Crum has worked at churches in in Massillon, Warren, Campbell, Ravenna, Orwell, Canton, Boardman, Rootstown and Youngstown

JudyJones - 6/11/2009 9:30 PM
For more information: Judy Block Jones, SNAP director southeastern Ohio,636-433-2511 David Clohessy, SNAP National Director: 314-566-9790, 314-645-5915 Another victim of just-ousted priest comes forward Man contacts confidential support group called SNAP He begs that the cleric ‘never be allowed near children’ Abuse started in late 1960's St Louis church in Louisville, Ohio SNAP urges him, and other victims and witnesses, to call police A confidential support group for clergy molestation victims is reporting that another victim of Fr. Thomas Crum has come forward. Yesterday afternoon, a leader in SNAP, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, was called by an Ohio man who says that as a child, he was sexually violated by Crum. “He specifically said that he wants us to let the public know that this priest did NOT just sexually abuse one child,” said Judy Jones, SNAP’s southeastern Ohio director. “This brave person came forward because he worries that more victims are still silent and that Crum has likely molested a number of kids.” The victim reports that the crimes started in the late 1960s, before Crum was ordained a priest, and continued after he was ordained. Crum was known to make friends with families, and therefore had easy access to kids. Jones says she fears there could be recent abuse by this priest. “Rarely do pedophiles ever stop assaulting children,” Jones stressed. “It usually takes decades before victims realize they’re not alone, they’ve been deeply hurt, they have options, and have a duty to try and protect others. Then, victims have to find the strength to speak up. It just takes time.” "If Bishop Murry did actually ask Fr Crum whether he abused others children, then someone is not telling the truth," said SNAP director David Clohessy. SNAP encouraged this new victim to contact law enforcement, as they do everyone who reports having been victimized. continued:
Most Popular
Convicted Stalker Is Prime Suspect in Teacher's Slaying
The woman was found dead in a Carriage Hill parking lot Wednesday morning. An aggravated murder warrant has been issued for a man previously convicted of stalking her and police are seeking the public's help in locating him. Video Video
Dog Found With Portion of Leg, Tail Cut Off
The dog is estimated to be about a year old and she is scheduled to have surgery on Thursday. Video Video
Deputy Agrees to Retire or Resign After Investigation
A Mahoning County sheriff's deputy has agreed to retire or resign after an internal investigation. He also resigned from the YSU police department. Video Video
News Poll
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.